jehnt
bsg 4x01, he that believeth in me (oh seriously, why is this the title?) 
5th-Apr-2008 05:40 pm
So, Battlestar Galactica. They really should just rename it the Watch Kara Thrace Go Crazy Show, because I have begun to understand that's what happens. Think about it. Most characters, between seasons, just go on their merry way and it's like, eh, no biggie, we'll pick up later. KARA, however, goes on a demented vacation to destroyed!Caprica, gets kidnapped and held captive by a twisted cylon who is obsessed with her, and then dies after being counseled by a vision of said cylon that it is The Thing To THEN returns from the dead. For all of the people who think Kara fans are Kara apologists... apologist, really? Do I have to apologize for her being a fucked-up bitch when it is QUITE CLEAR that she is a justifiably fucked-up bitch? I don't think so.

With that said, I think I may just like Kara more the crazier she gets. I mean, it's not liking her in the simple way I like, say, Helo, but it certainly keeps things interesting (not that Helo doesn't keep things interesting -- I mean, he had to shoot his wife and then there was that whole Helotown thing and ALSO he's going to be working with Joss, so w00t).

And when Kara climbed out of her viper, she was so proud that she'd found Earth. Did you see that cocky grin she shot Adama? She was like, "bitch, I FOUND your lost planet, so somebody go get me my frakkin top gun mug and pour me one while I lord it over your sorry asses," except then that wasn't what happened and she was so confused and hurt. I wanted to hug her.

I was impressed that Baltar seemed, for the first time in the show, to actually care about somebody other than himself. It tugged at my heartstrings. Or whatever. But I've seen too much of his selfishness in this show to really believe it. Also, thank frakking god they shaved that mess off his face. Best moment in the episode.

ALSO: LEE'S SWEATER OF SWEATERY HOTNESS. DID YOU SEE IT? IT WAS HOT.

Roslin staying with Adama = win.

Roslin + Caprica!Six = they need more scenes together.

Lee and Adama watching Starbuck blowing up again and again and again = oh my god, I bet they did that so much after she died, and I bet Lee cried emo tears and went to hug Anders. THIS SO HAPPENED.

Baltar's harem of men, women, and children (child?) = lolz.

Actually, most of this episode = lolz. I was pretty sure BSG "jumped the shark" at the end of the second season ("one year later" plots = shark-jumping, for sure), but much of the third season was decent enough to make me reconsider. AND THEN CAME EPISODE 19/20: ALL ALONG THE WATCHTOWER. It was enjoyable, yes, but it was enjoyable in the same way Prison Break is enjoyable. It was ridiculous. I laughed like a laughing thing. And I did the same all throughout this episode as well. The funniest scenes by far were the one where Baltar was "praying" and the woman was all "that's so beautiful! let's have sex!" and he was like "uh?" and then the scene where Anders was all "if you're a cylon, you've been one from the start, and that doesn't change who you are" and Kara looked at him like he had just brought the EXTREME CRAZY and was like "bitch, if you were a cylon I'd shoot you in the head," and my friends and I were crying we were laughing so hard. Poor Anders. He's so hot, and so confused, and so hot.

Also full of lolitude was the scene where Adama and Roslin were all "THERE COULD BE CYLONS RIGHT HERE OMG" while standing with Tigh, Tori, and Tyrol.


Also, this episode further confirmed my "BSG = DS9 mk II" theory. I would elaborate on this further except I don't think there's anyone on my f-list who has seen all of both shows, and I don't want to type it all out if it's just going to not make sense to anyone. But seriously.
jehnt: (bsg - starbuck)
Comments 
6th-Apr-2008 12:18 am (UTC)
Roslin + Caprica!Six = they need more scenes together.

Lee and Adama watching Starbuck blowing up again and again and again = oh my god, I bet they did that so much after she died, and I bet Lee cried emo tears and went to hug Anders. THIS SO HAPPENED.


IAWTC

And also this: It was enjoyable, yes, but it was enjoyable in the same way Prison Break is enjoyable. It was ridiculous. I laughed like a laughing thing. And I did the same all throughout this episode as well.

I don't think the show is quite the second coming that the critics do, but when it is enjoyable, it is HELLA enjoyable. When it's not - stretches of the second half of season 2 and the second half of season 3 - it's boring at best and unbearable at worst. But as long as Kara, Adama, Roslin, and Caprica Six are around, I am happy.
ext_1310: (Default)
7th-Apr-2008 02:33 am (UTC)
I don't think the show is quite the second coming that the critics do

I've always found that critics have skewed ideas of what is good. I also think most of them stay far away from science fiction due to its gutter-quality reputation and so have no idea that it's pretty standard for sci fi shows to tackle complicated/controversial moral and political issues by using the alternate setting to gain some perspective, and so when they saw this in BSG they were disproportionately impressed.

But as long as Kara, Adama, Roslin, and Caprica Six are around, I am happy.

Yeah, the characters are definitely the show's #1 strength. They're all so interesting! I really want to find out more about Caprica Six this season. They've had her sitting in the Galactica's brig for a while but haven't given her much story yet -- I feel like it's because the writers haven't know what to do with her but hopefully since there are now more cylons on board that will change.
10th-Apr-2008 04:56 pm (UTC)
I also think most of them stay far away from science fiction due to its gutter-quality reputation and so have no idea that it's pretty standard for sci fi shows to tackle complicated/controversial moral and political issues by using the alternate setting to gain some perspective, and so when they saw this in BSG they were disproportionately impressed.

*nod*

I really want to find out more about Caprica Six this season

I especially want scenes of her with Roslin and with Starbuck. And possibly with Adama.
ext_1310: (Default)
This page was loaded Feb 2nd 2026, 2:04 pm GMT.