jehnt
on badfic and password-protected fic, among other things 
5th-Mar-2006 06:01 am
We're trying something new today. Have a song: Dizzee Rascal - Fix Up Look Sharp (Ratatat remix).

[Poll #685068]

So, I was reading this one fic, and it wasn't great but it also wasn't that bad. Then I reached this paragraph:

"Well, my name, as Professor McGonagall was so nice to point out is Tiel Azorleah. My father was. . . well, I don't know what he was. But it was neither British nor American. My name is a bit of a mouthful, and I fell dreadfully old when you call me Professor Azorleah, so call me simply RaspberrrySquirrel, or Raspberry for short. Don't ask how I got the name, just be grateful I'm not making you call me Professor Tiel Itiriaty Senelen Azorleah, which is my full name."

...

...

...

There was also a mint-green flying squirrel named Joe who was really a shapeshifter who shapeshifts into a Furby a lot. This then inspires Harry to get Draco a Furby for Christmas.

How do people even COME UP with this stuff????

*Jehnt cries*

I know, I know, I should stay away from the badfic. But how can I when it's just so ... fascinating. Or whatever it is. Also, bonus badpoints for Harry calling Draco "a silver-haired bishounen." Oh man, and even MORE badpoints for the best spell ever -- "freezious," which McGonagall uses to freeze a food-fight. +10 badpoints for showing lack of knowledge of Latin, ooooooh.

Scary typos I've found in fics, or Why You Should Have a Beta:

"He looked up once, to glance at Draco as the blond sat down a few rows back, across the isle."

[Damn small island they're on, eh?]

"Harry," Draco said, "Try to be more discrete."

[It makes me think of Harry scrunching his face up and clenching his fists and trying REALLY HARD to coalesce into a more distinct being.]

"I am a Malfoy, and, as such, would never renegade on a promise!"

[Errr, what?]

"For all he knew it could be some rouge Death Eater who was trying to kill him by first earning his trust through a love letter and then once Harry actually believed him he would move in for the kill and attack with a group of his fellow rouge Death Eaters and Harry would be dead."

[Now, am I wrong in assuming that these are Death Eaters who wear too much blush? Possibly Death Eaters who are into stage acting?]


You know what I don't really understand? Password-protected or f-locked fic.

I just don't get it. It really frustrates me. I'm far too lazy to jump through hoops in order to read something. It could be touted as the most brilliant fanfic in the history of fanfics ... but if I had to email someone in order to get the password, sign up for an account at the website, or subscribe to a yahoo group in order to read it, I'd just as soon pass.

Does anyone have any insight as to why people lock down fic in this way?

Also, hi! Look at me, all posting and whatnot!

ETA: lookit how I prettified my journal. *swoons* stripes yay!
jehnt: (Default)
Comments 
5th-Mar-2006 12:22 pm (UTC)
//I know, I know, I should stay away from the badfic. But how can I when it's just so ... fascinating.//

So are train wracks ;-)
5th-Mar-2006 01:37 pm (UTC)
Well, yes, but no one DIES of bad fic. Except metaphorically, of course. I metaphorically die of bad fic ALL THE TIME.

But you must admit the "Draco sat a few rows back, across the isle" line is good (for a certain value of "good," at any rate). I'm totally writing something one day where everyone is on a VERY SMALL ISLAND because I'm sure there are other amusingly tragic things that could happen.
5th-Mar-2006 01:44 pm (UTC)
my brain will not let go of:
But No man is an island.

so there, brain, i typed it.. happy now?
5th-Mar-2006 01:52 pm (UTC)
Brains are silly like that. Sometimes they come up with something and WILL NOT REST until you've said it. I've said strange/pointless things more times than I can count because of that.
5th-Mar-2006 02:59 pm (UTC)
Ah, funny typos! I love those, but only when I'm reading them out of context. No matter how funny they are, they interrupt my reading more than if a bomb exploded outside my door. Okay, maybe not so much, but still.

I never lock my fics myself. I have one fic on a password-protected archive, but I'm thinking of pulling it down (if only I could figure out how! It's so confusing). I f-lock almost everything on my journal except for things that are supposed to be read by anyone and everyone -- i.e. fics, fandom- or writing-related discussion, etc. I assume that people who password-protect their fics do it because of underage people who might not dare to outright lie to get the password. Maybe when some people f-lock their fics, it's also because of the same reason, or maybe they are just shy about their writing, or maybe it's something to do with RL issues.
5th-Mar-2006 11:49 pm (UTC)
i have a good friend that flocks all her fic. she's got underage children and is v. concerned/aware of underage kiddies getting at her racy fic. she doesn't want them to, so she flocks.

there are a lot of valid reasons for locking down fic (like laws about contributing to the delinquency of a minor, RL work concerns, family that read one's journal). i've considered it. [*shrugs*]
22nd-Mar-2006 12:09 am (UTC)
A scary thought is that I actually read that green squirrel fic. Maybe even listed it among other animal fics.

I guess they are just very young? The authors, I mean. I know that when I was 12 or 13, we invented scarily stupid things with friends during lessons. Maybe they write fanfic instead of writing down lectures?
22nd-Mar-2006 07:22 am (UTC)
It doesn't surprise me that you've read it -- I'm pretty sure I got it from your list of epistolary fiction.

I know that's probably the reason, but it's still difficult for me to understand. When I was 12ish I wrote Star Trek genfic with the intent of getting it published in the Strange New Worlds anthology. No Mary Sues or green squirrels to be found, although there were strange aliens. But there are strange aliens on every episode of Star Trek, so that's not particularly strange. Mary Sues were only ever a problem for young!me in original fiction, where I named them things like Ravija Elisa Sienra Alette and made them have distant relatives that were elves so I could highlight the racial tensions between the elvish and human nations. Oh snap. I was really fond of writing about racial tension. There were riots! Burnings! Sit-ins!
This page was loaded Jul 7th 2025, 7:59 pm GMT.